Apr 3, 2011


RAF stretched to limit, air chief warns

Exclusive: Air Chief Marshal says it can cope with planned six months in Libya but extra cash required in 2014-15 review
Air chief marshal Sir Stephen Dalton
'If we are to meet the requirements laid upon us, there is no question that more investment will be needed to achieve that,' says Sir Stephen Dalton. Photograph: Felix Clay for the Guardian
The head of the RAF has issued a blunt warning that the service will need "genuine increases" in its budget over the coming years if it is to continue running the range of operations ministers demand.
In an interview with the Guardian, Air Chief Marshal Sir Stephen Dalton said he was trying to protect the core of the RAF during a turbulent period of spending cuts and redundancies, but insisted ministers would have to sanction proper reinvestment.
With the RAF playing an important role in Libya, where bombers, fighter jets and surveillance aircraft have all been involved over the past fortnight, he admitted the service was now stretched to the limit.
Dalton, 57, said the RAF was planning to continue operations over Libya for at least six months. His assumption is that planes will be needed "for a number of months rather than a number of days or weeks".
His warning comes amid renewed signs that key figures in Muammar Gaddafi's regime are seeking an end to the crisis. The country's deputy foreign minister, Abdul Ati al-Obeidi, flew to Greece on Sunday using the same route out of Libya as his former boss, Moussa Koussa. It was suggested he was in Athens to bring new proposals for a ceasefire or discuss the terms of Gaddafi's departure.
Even as the Libyan conflict continues, the financial difficulties faced by all three British armed services will be underlined on Monday when the army and the Royal Navy set out their redundancy programmes, despite calls from former service chiefs and Labour that the schemes should be shelved because of ongoing operations in north Africa and Afghanistan.
Dalton accepted the need for reform, but made clear that the RAF would need an "uplift" in spending.
"The key factor is that if we are to meet the requirements laid upon us, there is no question that more investment will be needed to achieve that. What I am seeking to do is maintain core competencies and bricks on which we can then build the future."
Dalton said extra cash was needed long before 2020, which is the target set by government for a wholesale revamping of UK defence strategy, and he claimed prime minister David Cameron had acknowledged this requirement.
"It needs to happen from the next comprehensive spending review, 2014-15. If at that point the economy has recovered as the government is predicting it should, they can then start to reinvest in some of the future capabilities we will need," said Dalton.
Without "genuine increases", the RAF would find it "very difficult to maintain levels of capability".
"On current planning, we can continue in Afghanistan, the Falklands and Libya with what we have got. But that does bring you nearer the point that you have just about exhausted the bag. It's a heck of a lot to be doing at one time," Dalton said.
The first of the service chiefs to speak out about the current funding crisis, Dalton dismissed outright any suggestion that the RAF might be merged with the army or the navy to save money and said it was inconceivable that the RAF would ever want to scale back and lose its global reach.
He also acknowledged that morale had been affected by a massive reduction in the Ministry of Defence's budget – 8% in real terms.
"People do feel concerned. Of course they feel concerned, they have a professional pride in what they do. They don't join the RAF as if they are joining a bank or an insurance company. They join the RAF because they want to be part of something that does something much bigger and better and, most importantly, has some meaning and value for everyone," Dalton said.
"So of course they are concerned. The world has become a very much more unstable place and again we have seen that in the last few days.
"They also think there is a need to make sure the government, the public, understands what they do, and understands that they are prepared to do these things provided what they do is recognised."
Dalton was appointed chief of the air staff in July 2009 and is overseeing one of the most radical overhauls in the history of the service. In last year's strategic defence and security review, ministers set out proposals to cut 17,000 jobs from the armed forces – 7,000 from the army and 5,000 each from the RAF and the navy.
The MoD believes a 6,000 cut can be achieved by not replacing people who have left, but that still leaves another 11,000 jobs to axe.
The RAF set out its redundancy programme last month. It is to close its base at Kinloss in Scotland and withdraw two squadrons of Tornados in the summer.
The remains of the Tornado fleet was thought to be vulnerable as the MoD has a £1bn overspend to cover from last year's budget alone. But it is now assumed that the Treasury would not dare push for the rapid withdrawal of the ground attack aircraft because they have been so instrumental in the campaign against Gaddafi. Eight Tornados and 10 Typhoons are currently in Italy, helping to secure the no-fly zone.
Dalton said the Nimrod R1, which was due to be scrapped, had been reprieved for as long as it was needed in Libya.

Prison Term for Executive in Tongan Ferry Disaster

WELLINGTON, New Zealand (AP) — A shipping company chief was sentenced to five years in prison and his corporation fined more than $1 million on Monday for negligence in a ferry disaster in Tonga that killed 74 people.
John Jonesse, 62, was sentenced to five years in Tonga's Huatolitoli Prison on a variety of charges relating to the sinking of the Princess Ashika, including manslaughter by negligence and forgery, Tongan media reported.
Ferry captain Viliami Tuputupu was sentenced to four years in prison for manslaughter by negligence, but will serve only six months after Justice Robert Schuster suspended most of his sentence.
First mate Semisi Pomale was sentenced to five years on one charge of manslaughter by negligence and five of sending an unseaworthy ship to sea, but will serve only 18 months after part of the sentence was suspended.
The manslaughter charges related to Vaefetu'u Mahe, a 22-year-old woman whose body was one of only two recovered after the sinking of vessel on August 5, 2009.
A total of 74 passengers and crew died, including all of the women and children on board who were sleeping below decks when the ferry sank.
The former acting director of the government's marine department, Viliami Tu'ipulotu, was sentenced to three years imprisonment on one charge of manslaughter by negligence and five of sending an unseaworthy ship to sea. His entire sentence was suspended.
The ferry operator, the government-owned Shipping Corporation of Polynesia, was fined a total of 2 million Tongan pa'anga ($1 million) for manslaughter by negligence and for sending an unseaworthy ship to sea, the Matangi Tonga website reported.
The four men and the corporation were found guilty on Friday by a jury after a seven-week trial.
The court heard testimony about water leaking below decks hours before the vessel sank in rough seas. The jury viewed photographs showing the Ashika full of holes and heavily rusted when it arrived in Tonga a month before it sank, Matangi Tonga reported.
The tragedy shocked Tonga, a genteel South Pacific nation of more than 175 islands that relies heavily on ferries to transport people and goods between atolls.

Libya Releases Al-Jazeera Reporter; 3 Others Held

DUBAI, United Arab Emirates (AP) — The Arabic news channel Al-Jazeera says one of the network's four reporters who were captured in Libya last month by pro-Gadhafi forces has been released. Three others remain held.
In a statement emailed to the AP on Monday, Al-Jazeera says the journalist who has been released is Lotfi al-Massoudi of Tunisia. The four journalists from the Qatar-based network were captured in the western Libya 27 days ago, the statement says.
The three who are still being held in Libya are: Ahmed Vall Ouldeddin of Mauritania, Ammar al-Hamdan of Norway and Kamel al-Tallou of Britain.
While the network staff were "glad to see an end to the ordeal" of al-Massoudi, the statement called for an "immediate release" of his three colleagues.

Nazarbayev Wins Landslide Victory in Kazakhstan




ASTANA, Kazakhstan — Preliminary results show that Kazakhstan’s president, Nursultan A. Nazarbayev, has won re-election by a colossal 95.5 percent, authorities announced on Monday, ushering in a third decade in power for the man who has led the oil-rich region since the late Soviet period.
James Hill for The New York Times
A polling station in Astana. The incumbent has been praised for making the nation stable but criticized for stifling dissent.
Perhaps more relevant for authorities was a reported turnout of 89.9 percent, remarkable given that Mr. Nazarbayev’s three opponents were too weak to pose any real competition and the outcome was not in doubt.
Major opposition parties refused to participate in the elections and encouraged voters to boycott the polls, but lines snaked out of voting stations starting early on Sunday morning, seemingly affirming Mr. Nazarbayev’s popularity during a season of street uprisings in other parts of the world.
The results were met triumphantly in Astana, the futuristic capital that Mr. Nazarbayev ordered built in the northern steppe. Kazakhstan boasts immense reserves of oil and gas, which have boosted per capita GDP from around $700 to more than $8,000 since the early 1990s.
“You don’t win an election on election day, but much earlier, with your deeds, with all we have done these 20 years,” Mr. Nazarbayev told members of his Nur Otan party, which holds every seat in the country’s lower house of Parliament. “This is the grade of the examination which we have passed.”
This spring’s hasty campaign season in Kazakhstan has sometimes felt like a pep rally for Mr. Nazarbayev, an effect that was heightened when one of the his three opponents  acknowledged that he, too, had voted for the president .
 “I am sure that the current president will be the victor, so I am giving him my vote as well,” the challenger, Mels Yeleusizov, an environmental activist, told the Interfax news service as he emerged from a polling station in the city of Almaty. He said his family was voting for Mr. Nazarbayev as well.
Mr. Nazarbayev, 70,  has drawn criticism from the West for stifling dissent, and no previous election has been judged free and fair by international observers. In February, seeking to shore up his reputation as an international statesman, Mr. Nazarbayev abruptly rejected the idea of a referendum that would have granted him the presidency until 2020. The election provided an even playing field, he told reporters on Sunday.
“All candidates had equal opportunities to visit regions and had access to mass media,” Mr. Nazarbayev said on Sunday, as he emerged from the country’s National Academic Library, a grandiose new structure that is shaped like a Möbius strip. “They expressed their ideas and unveiled their messages to the people of Kazakhstan. There are some valuable thoughts that we have to keep in mind. We are open to our society.”
In Semey, a university city near the border with Siberia, students showed up in large numbers in a snowstorm on Sunday morning, and poll workers said there were already lines when they opened the doors at 7 a.m.
Tolebay K. Rakhypbekov, rector of the Semey State Medical University, said political competition would come to Kazakhstan — but only gradually.
“There is none now,” he said. “But what competition can there be against our president? We all love him.”
Lyudmila A. Lyapunova, 60, said voters were there because they risked losing their jobs or university spots if they did not show up. As a retiree, she said, she could afford to openly denounce the process, and planned to cross out every name on the ballot: an improvised version of “against all,” a traditional option that was omitted from this year’s poll.
But virtually all voters said they were casting ballots for the president. Ada G. Komanova, 76, raved over the services provided to the elderly through the Nazarbayev Fund: a health clinic, concerts, a senior center “so cozy, it’s like a fairy tale.”
Kanat, a construction worker who would not give his last name, said he had voted for Mr. Nazarbayev, even though he thought the president and his family had enriched themselves fabulously during the past two decades.
“They already have everything they need,” he said. “They can afford to think about the public.”

Libya: Turkish ship rescues injured from Misrata

Misrata evacuees share their stories with the BBC's Christian Fraser
A Turkish humanitarian ship carrying more than 250 injured people from the Libyan city of Misrata has arrived in the rebel stronghold of Benghazi.
Misrata, the only city in the west still controlled by the rebels, has been under siege by forces loyal to Col Muammar Gaddafi for several weeks.
Doctors on board the ship said many people had extremely serious injuries.
Meanwhile, the eastern oil town of Brega has seen continued fighting between rebels and pro-Gaddafi forces.
A BBC correspondent says an uneasy stalemate is developing.

Start Quote

We have no water, no electricity. We don't have medicine. There are snipers everywhere”
Ibrahim al-AradiInjured Misrata resident
Government troops are reported to be holding ground near its university, but are reluctant to engage rebels because of the risk of Nato air strikes.
The poorly armed and disorganised rebel forces are unable or unwilling to push on towards Brega and are calling for more help from the West.
Libya's Deputy Foreign Minister, Abdul Ati al-Obeidi, has told the Greek prime minister that Col Gaddafi wants the fighting to end.
"From the Libyan envoy's comments it appears that the regime is seeking a solution," Greek Foreign Minister Dimitris Droutsas told reporters.
Mr Droutsas said Athens had stressed the international community's call for Libya to comply with UN Security Council resolution 1973, which authorised military intervention to protect civilians.
The Libyan envoy would be going on to Turkey on Monday and then Malta to continue his diplomatic contacts, he added.
Amputations
Turkey's Foreign Minister, Ahmet Davutoglu, ordered the Ankara, a car ferry that had been turned into a makeshift hospital, into Misrata on Sunday after it had spend four days waiting for permission to dock.
A wounded boy lies on a mattress on a Turkish humanitarian ship (3 April 2011)Twelve-year-old Muhammad was peppered with shrapnel when a rocket exploded near him
The ship, which was also carrying medical supplies for doctors in Misrata, arrived under cover from 10 Turkish F-16 fighter jets and two navy frigates, Turkish consular official Ali Akin told the Reuters news agency.
With heavily armed Turkish police special forces standing by, the injured people were taken aboard and laid on mattresses on one of the car decks, above which saline drips were hung. Some were accompanied by their relatives.
Mr Akin said the ship had to leave early after a large crowd - including hundreds of Egyptians - pressed forward on the quayside hoping to escape.
The BBC's Jon Leyne, who went on board the Ankara, says many of the patients have extremely serious injuries, including some amputations.
One man lost part of his leg in an explosion as he was taking his wife into hospital for treatment. A 13-year-old boy described how he was shot by a sniper. A 12 year old was peppered with shrapnel when a rocket exploded near him when he and his brother were on their way to the market.
Mohammed Muftah, who had shrapnel wounds on his legs, back and neck, said Col Gaddafi's troops had "killed entire families".
"I have a neighbour who lost his wife and his three children," he told the AFP news agency. "They did it just to terrorise people."
Our correspondent says everyone had stories of the ever worsening conditions in Misrata. They told him that much of the city had no water or electricity and no-one was safe from shelling or sniper-fire.
Rebel supporters welcome the Turkish humanitarian ship in Benghazi (3 April 2011)As the ship arrived in Benghazi several hundred rebel supporters waved and cheered on the quayside
"It is very, very bad. In my street, Gaddafi bombed us," Ibrahim al-Aradi, who had wounds in his groin, told Reuters. "We have no water, no electricity. We don't have medicine. There are snipers everywhere."
Doctors on board say medical care conditions Misrata were inadequate, and that more than 200 people had been killed and hundreds more wounded. One unconfirmed report said 160 may have died this week.
At least one person was killed and several wounded early on Sunday when government forces shelled a building in Misrata, a resident told Reuters.
As the ship arrived in Benghazi several hundred rebel supporters waiting on the quayside chanted: "The blood of martyrs is spilled for freedom."
The Ankara would pick up about 100 more wounded before setting sail for the Turkish port of Cesme, where the casualties would be treated in a well-equipped, well-supplied, modern hospital, officials said.
Stalemate
To the east of Benghazi, government troops continued to hold ground near the university in Brega, trading rocket and artillery fire with the rebels.
The BBC's Orla Guerin reports on the stalemate developing near Brega
The rebel Transitional National Council has appealed for new Nato air strikes, as well as weapons and military training to be provided by foreign governments.
They have acknowledged that rebel fighters firing in the air through lack of discipline could have provoked the Nato air strike on a rebel convoy on Friday, which left at least 13 people dead.
The rebel military commanders say they are trying to bring a new professionalism to its military campaign. Road blocks have been set up close to the frontline and only soldiers with at least some training are allowed through.
Iman Bugaighis, a spokeswoman for the rebel council, told the BBC: "We have reorganised our troops. Now the army is in the front and then followed by our volunteers who are fighting with the army."
Archbishop Desmond Tutu of South Africa meanwhile called for a swift end to the conflict, even if it meant offering Col Gaddafi safe haven in another country.
Libya map
Are you in Libya? Send us your comments and experiences.
Send your pictures and videos to yourpics@bbc.co.uk or text them to61124 (UK) or +44 7725 100 100 (International). If you have a large file you can upload here.